Simple Past vs. Present Perfect

  • -Where you (find) this knife?
    - I (find) it in the garden
    -Why you (not leave) it there?

    Не могу понять какое время тут нужно употрибить, и по какому правилу.

  • Present perfect, если никакого контекста, ведь отсылки к прошедшему нет, или там тоже есть контекст? Тогда может быть и past simple.

  • Привильный ответ по книге - SImpe Past

  • Не исключено. Что за книга?

  • Я не знаю, она у преподаватильницы.

  • The Past Indefinite is also used in special questions beginning with where and how when they refer to the past events.

    Where is my hat? Where did I leave my hat?"

    The question Where have you been? can be asked of the person who has just come.

    'Hello, Mum. I'm sorry I'm late" "Where have you been?"

    In all other cases it should be Where were you?

    "Did the party go off nicely?" "I don't know. I wasn't there." "Where were you?'

    Have you had a good holiday? (You have just returned)

    Did you have a good holiday? (Your holiday finished some time before the question)

    Вот этот учебник. Как я и говорила , всё зависит от контекста.

    Скрыть комментарии

  • Спасибо